In short
The 1-10-100 rule says a defect costs roughly 1 unit to fix at the source, 10 once it reaches your warehouse and 100 at the customer's site. The figures are a rule of thumb, but the lesson is real: inspect incoming material, in-process hold points and finished goods before shipment.
The 1-10-100 rule of quality is a simple way to think about the cost of defects. Preventing or catching a problem at the source costs 1 unit. Catching it later, inside your own operation, costs around 10. Letting it reach your customer costs around 100. The numbers are a rule of thumb, often attributed to George Labovitz and Yu Sang Chang in the early 1990s, not a precise measurement. But anyone who has dealt with a rejected shipment of steel components knows the direction is right – and in cross-border sourcing the multiplier can be steeper.
The 1-10-100 rule applied to sourced components
For a buyer sourcing welded assemblies, castings or machined parts from an overseas manufacturer, the three stages look like this.
1 – At the factory
A wrong dimension found at the machine, or a weld defect found before painting, is corrected where the tools, materials and people already are. The cost is rework time, perhaps a scrapped part, and a short delay.
10 – At your warehouse
The same defect found at goods receipt is a different problem. The parts have been packed, shipped, cleared through customs and probably paid for. Now you need to quarantine stock, document the defect, agree responsibility with the supplier, and then rework locally, return goods across a border or wait for replacements – while production planning waits too.
100 – At your customer's site
If the defect reaches your customer, costs multiply again: field rework or replacement, travel, downtime on the customer's line or project, possible warranty and liability claims, and damage to a relationship that may have taken years to build. In applications such as pressure equipment or load-bearing structures, a defect at this stage can also become a safety issue.
Why the multiplier is higher in international sourcing
Distance adds cost at every step after the factory gate:
- Freight and logistics costs are spent before the defect is discovered, and spent again for returns or replacements.
- Lead times are longer, so a replacement batch can mean weeks of delay rather than days.
- Sending parts back for rework is often impractical, so local repair at your own cost becomes the fastest option.
- Commercial recovery is slower: establishing responsibility across borders and languages takes time and documentation.
The actual figures depend entirely on the product, the contract and the customer. The point is not the exact ratio but the pattern: each stage a defect survives adds another layer of cost.
There is also a stage before the "1". Many defects are cheapest to deal with before any metal is cut: an ambiguous tolerance clarified at drawing review, a material grade confirmed at order stage, or a weld detail discussed with the supplier's welding coordinator before the WPS is written. Some quality professionals describe this as prevention, and treat it as the least expensive point of all. A short technical review meeting with the manufacturer at the start of an order is often the most cost-effective quality activity in the whole project.
Practical inspection points that apply the rule
Applying the 1-10-100 rule means moving checks upstream. For fabricated and machined parts, three inspection points cover most of the risk.
1. Raw material inspection
Many serious defects begin with the wrong material. Before cutting starts, check:
- Mill certificates – typically EN 10204 type 3.1 for structural and pressure applications – against the specified grade and standard.
- Heat number traceability between the certificate and the markings on the plate, bar or pipe.
- Dimensions and condition of incoming material, for example plate thickness tolerance, laminations or corrosion.
2. In-process inspection
In-process checks catch problems while they can still be corrected cheaply. Examples:
- First-off inspection after machine set-up, before the rest of the batch is run.
- Fit-up and dimensional checks before welding, while distortion can still be controlled.
- Visual weld inspection and any specified non-destructive testing before painting or galvanising hides the surface.
- Coating thickness and adhesion checks before final assembly.
3. Pre-shipment inspection
The final checkpoint before goods leave the factory confirms that the finished lot matches the drawing, the approved sample and the order. It typically covers dimensions, visual quality, function where relevant, marking, documentation and packing. Once the container is sealed, you are on the 10 side of the rule.
Building the rule into your supply chain
Inspection alone does not create quality; it measures it. The strongest use of the 1-10-100 rule is to agree upfront with the supplier where checks happen and what evidence is produced. An inspection and test plan (ITP) lists each characteristic, the method, the acceptance criteria, who performs the check, and whether the buyer must witness or review it before work continues.
- Agree the drawing revision, applicable standards and acceptance criteria before the order.
- Approve a golden sample or first article.
- Define hold points in the ITP, such as material verification and pre-paint weld inspection.
- Collect records at each stage, not only at the end.
- Feed defects back to the supplier as corrective actions, so they are prevented next time rather than found again.
How ISY Supply works with the rule
Because ISY Supply is based in Türkiye, its team can be at the factory during the stages where the "1" applies – material checks, in-process visits and pre-shipment inspection – rather than relying only on documents sent after the fact. The inspection scope is agreed with each client according to the product and its risk.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the 1-10-100 rule in quality management?
A rule of thumb that preventing or catching a defect at the source costs 1 unit, correcting it later inside your organisation costs around 10, and fixing it after it reaches the customer costs around 100.
Who created the 1-10-100 rule?
It is commonly attributed to George Labovitz and Yu Sang Chang in the early 1990s. The ratios are illustrative and should not be treated as measured constants.
Where should inspections take place for sourced metal parts?
At least at raw material receipt, at key in-process hold points such as before welding and before coating, and at a pre-shipment inspection before the container is loaded.
Is incoming inspection at my warehouse still necessary?
A basic receiving check for quantity, transport damage and documentation is still worthwhile. But it should confirm that upstream controls worked, not be the first point at which quality is checked.




