In short

Under Incoterms 2020, FOB and CIF transfer risk at the same point: when goods are loaded on board at the port of shipment. CIF only adds that the seller pays freight and minimum insurance (Institute Cargo Clauses C, 110%). For containerised industrial goods, FCA or CIP is usually the better choice.

Choosing between FOB and CIF is one of the first decisions on an export purchase order, and it is often made by habit rather than analysis. Under Incoterms 2020, the two terms transfer risk from seller to buyer at exactly the same point, yet they split cost, control and insurance very differently. For a buyer importing steel fabrications, machined parts or pressure equipment into Europe, that difference decides who chooses the ship, who holds the insurance policy and what happens when a container arrives damaged.

This guide explains FOB vs CIF in plain terms, shows where each leaves you exposed, and when FCA or CIP is the better choice.

What FOB and CIF actually mean

FOB – Free On Board

Under FOB (named port of shipment), the seller clears the goods for export and delivers them on board the vessel nominated by the buyer at the agreed port. Risk passes to the buyer once the goods are on board. From that moment the buyer pays the ocean freight, arranges any insurance and carries the risk of loss or damage.

CIF – Cost, Insurance and Freight

Under CIF (named port of destination), the seller books and pays the main carriage to the destination port and must buy cargo insurance for the buyer's benefit. The catch: risk still passes to the buyer when the goods are on board the vessel at the port of shipment, just as under FOB. The seller pays for the voyage, but the buyer carries its risk.

FOB vs CIF at a glance

FOBCIF
Named placePort of shipment (e.g. FOB Izmir)Port of destination (e.g. CIF Rotterdam)
Risk transfersOn board the vessel at port of shipmentOn board the vessel at port of shipment
Main freight booked and paid byBuyerSeller
Cargo insuranceNot required; buyer decidesSeller must buy minimum cover: Institute Cargo Clauses (C), 110% of contract price
Export clearanceSellerSeller
Import clearance and dutiesBuyerBuyer
Control of carrier and scheduleBuyerSeller
Transport modeSea and inland waterway onlySea and inland waterway only

Why CIF minimum insurance may not be enough

Incoterms 2020 requires the CIF seller to obtain insurance complying with Institute Cargo Clauses (C), or similar clauses, for at least the contract price plus 10% (110%), in the currency of the contract. Clauses (C) is the most limited of the standard sets. It covers named major casualties – broadly fire or explosion, the vessel stranding, sinking or capsizing, collision, overturning of land transport, jettison and general average – rather than all risks.

For industrial cargo, the losses that actually occur are often not on that list. Typical gaps include:

  • Water damage from condensation or rain ingress in a container, which can corrode machined surfaces and bare steel.
  • Handling damage during loading, transhipment or discharge, such as dented vessels, bent frames or cracked castings.
  • Theft or non-delivery of part of a consignment.
  • Damage caused by insufficient packing, which is excluded under the standard clauses and makes packing specifications part of your risk management.

Institute Cargo Clauses (A) offers much broader cover, subject to its own exclusions. Under CIF the parties can agree that the seller buys (A) cover, but it has to be written into the contract; otherwise (C) satisfies the rule. Incoterms 2020 raised the default for CIP to Clauses (A) while leaving CIF at (C) – a useful hint about which term suits high-value manufactured goods.

There is also a practical issue. Under CIF, the policy is arranged by the seller with an insurer of the seller's choice, often in another country. If you need to claim, you are relying on a policy you did not negotiate. Many European buyers prefer to hold their own open cargo policy and buy on terms that leave insurance with them.

Hidden costs and loss of control under CIF

CIF can look cheaper because the seller quotes a single delivered-to-port price. But the seller chooses the carrier and routing, and the buyer usually pays destination charges such as terminal handling, documentation fees and any demurrage or detention once the container arrives. Depending on the carrier and port, those charges can be significant and are not visible when CIF prices are compared.

You also lose visibility. Under FOB or FCA, your own forwarder books the space, tracks the container and can warn you about delays early. Under CIF, that information sits with the seller's forwarder.

When to choose FOB, FCA or CIP instead

The right term depends on how the goods physically move and how much control you want. A practical guide:

  • FOB suits breakbulk or out-of-gauge cargo that is genuinely loaded onto the vessel at the quay – for example large tanks, silos or long structural sections – when you have your own forwarder and insurance.
  • FCA (named place) usually fits containerised goods better. The seller hands the goods to your carrier at its premises or at the terminal, and risk passes there. Incoterms 2020 also allows the parties to agree that the buyer instructs its carrier to issue an on-board bill of lading to the seller, which helps with letters of credit.
  • CIP is the container-friendly counterpart of CIF. The seller pays carriage to the named destination and must insure with Institute Cargo Clauses (A) by default, while risk passes when the goods are handed to the first carrier.
  • CIF remains workable for bulk commodities, or when the buyer has no forwarding set-up, provided the insurance level is upgraded in the contract.

The ICC guidance notes that FOB and CIF are not appropriate where goods are handed over to the carrier before they are loaded on board, as is typical with containers delivered to a terminal. The seller would otherwise carry risk during a period it does not control.

Checklist before you agree delivery terms

  1. Name the Incoterm with its version and an exact place, for example "FCA Denizli, seller's premises, Incoterms 2020" or "CIF Rotterdam, Incoterms 2020".
  2. State the required insurance cover – clauses and percentage – in the purchase order, not just "insured".
  3. Agree packing, preservation and lashing specifications, because insufficient packing is excluded from cover.
  4. Clarify destination charges and who pays them.
  5. Define the documents needed: commercial invoice, packing list, bill of lading, insurance certificate, and origin or movement certificates such as A.TR for goods from Türkiye.

Remember that Incoterms do not deal with transfer of ownership, payment or remedies for defective goods. Those belong in the sales contract.

How ISY Supply approaches delivery terms

For shipments from Türkiye, ISY Supply discusses the delivery term with each client at quotation stage: whether the cargo is containerised or project cargo, whether the client has its own forwarder and insurance, and where the goods need to arrive. Packing, loading and shipping documents are then coordinated with the manufacturer so that the term on paper matches how the goods actually move.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does risk transfer at the destination port under CIF?

No. Under CIF in Incoterms 2020, risk passes to the buyer when the goods are on board the vessel at the port of shipment, even though the seller pays freight to the destination port.

What insurance does CIF require under Incoterms 2020?

The seller must provide at least Institute Cargo Clauses (C) cover, or similar, for 110% of the contract price. Buyers who need broader cover should require Clauses (A) in the contract.

Is FOB suitable for container shipments?

It is widely used, but the ICC recommends FCA for containers, because the goods are usually handed over at a terminal before loading and FOB leaves the seller carrying risk it cannot control.

What is the difference between CIF and CIP?

CIF is for sea and inland waterway transport, transfers risk on board at the port of shipment and requires minimum Clauses (C) insurance. CIP works for any mode, transfers risk at handover to the first carrier and requires Clauses (A) cover by default.

#incoterms 2020#fob#cif#cargo insurance#shipping