In short

EN 10204 defines material test documents: type 2.2 is a manufacturer's test report, 3.1 is certified by the manufacturer's independent inspection department, and 3.2 is additionally verified by the purchaser's or a third-party inspector. Always check that the heat number matches the material and that the values meet the standard.

A mill certificate – also called a mill test certificate, MTC or material test report – is the document that ties a piece of steel to its chemistry and mechanical properties. For structural steel, pressure vessels, pipelines and machined parts, it is often the only evidence that the material is what the drawing says it is. In Europe the type of document is defined by EN 10204, and the difference between a 2.2, 3.1 and 3.2 certificate matters more than many buyers realise.

EN 10204 document types

EN 10204:2004 defines four types of inspection document. The key distinction is between non-specific inspection – results from production of the same kind, not necessarily from the delivered material – and specific inspection, carried out on the products supplied or on test units of which they are part.

TypeNameTest basisValidated by
2.1Declaration of compliance with the orderNo test resultsManufacturer
2.2Test reportNon-specific inspectionManufacturer
3.1Inspection certificate 3.1Specific inspection of the delivered productsManufacturer's authorised inspection representative, independent of the manufacturing department
3.2Inspection certificate 3.2Specific inspection of the delivered productsManufacturer's independent representative and the purchaser's authorised representative or an inspector designated by official regulations

When a 2.2 test report is acceptable

A 2.2 test report can be appropriate for non-critical items where typical values are sufficient. It does not prove that your particular plate, bar or pipe was tested.

Why 3.1 is the common default

For structural, pressure-bearing and safety-relevant parts, 3.1 is the usual minimum, and many product and application standards require it. EN 1090-2, for example, calls for 3.1 documents for many structural steel grades, and pressure equipment materials are typically supplied with specific inspection documents. Always check what your applicable standard and specification require.

When 3.2 is worth paying for

A 3.2 certificate adds an independent witness: the purchaser's inspector or a third-party body attends or verifies the tests. It costs more and takes longer to arrange, so it is usually specified for critical applications, when a project specification demands it, or when the buyer has reason to doubt the supply chain.

How to check a mill certificate

A certificate is only useful if someone actually reads it. For every critical material certificate, work through these checks:

  1. Match the heat number. The heat (cast) number on the certificate must match the number stamped, stencilled or labelled on the material. If it does not match, the certificate does not belong to that material, whatever else it says.
  2. Confirm the grade and standard. Check the full designation, including delivery condition, for example S355J2+N to EN 10025-2 or P265GH to EN 10028-2. A certificate for S355JR does not prove S355J2 impact properties.
  3. Compare the chemical composition with the standard. Check each element and, where the standard specifies it, the carbon equivalent (CEV) against the limits for that grade and thickness.
  4. Compare the mechanical properties. Yield strength, tensile strength and elongation must meet the values for the actual thickness range, and impact energy must be reported at the correct test temperature – for J2 grades in EN 10025-2, 27 J at -20 °C.
  5. Check dimensions and quantities. Thickness, size and number of pieces or weight should correspond to the delivery.
  6. Check who signed it. A 3.1 must be validated by the mill's authorised inspection representative; a 3.2 also needs the validation of the purchaser's or third-party inspector.
  7. Check the issuer. The certificate should originate from the steel producer. If a stockholder supplies the material, expect the original mill certificate, or a stockholder document that clearly references it and maintains traceability.

Red flags on mill certificates

  • Heat numbers that cannot be found on the material, or markings that appear ground off or re-stamped.
  • Certificates that look retyped, with fonts, logos or layouts that do not match the mill's genuine documents.
  • Identical test values across several different heats, or values sitting suspiciously exactly on the minimum limits.
  • Missing impact test results for a grade that requires them, or impact tests at the wrong temperature.
  • A 3.1 certificate issued by a trader with no reference to the original mill document.
  • Thickness or dimensions on the certificate that do not match the delivered material.
  • Superseded standard designations that do not correspond to the grade you ordered.

None of these automatically proves fraud, but each should trigger questions before the material is cut. Once a plate becomes part of a welded assembly, re-establishing traceability is difficult and expensive. If in doubt, ask the mill to confirm the certificate number directly.

Maintaining traceability through fabrication

The mill certificate covers the material as delivered from the mill. Once a fabricator cuts plates into parts, traceability depends on the fabricator's own system: transferring heat numbers to cut pieces before the original marking is lost, keeping a cutting list or material traceability matrix that links each part to its certificate, and handing over that record with the final documentation.

For pressure equipment and for higher execution classes in structural steel, this traceability is required by the applicable standards rather than optional. For the final document package, ask for a material traceability list that maps each component, or each weld seam position, to its heat number and certificate.

How ISY Supply handles mill certificates

For orders where material properties matter, ISY Supply reviews mill certificates against the order specification and checks heat number markings on the material during factory visits, so that the certificate in the document package corresponds to the steel actually used. Where a client requires 3.2 certificates, this needs to be agreed before material is ordered, because the witnessed testing has to be arranged with the mill or a third-party body in advance.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between EN 10204 3.1 and 3.2?

Both report specific tests on the delivered material. A 3.1 is validated by the manufacturer's independent inspection representative; a 3.2 is additionally validated by the purchaser's authorised representative or an inspector designated by official regulations.

Is a 2.2 certificate enough for structural steel?

It depends on the specification and grade. Many structural and pressure applications require 3.1. A 2.2 reports non-specific results only and does not prove that your material was tested.

How can I verify that a mill certificate is genuine?

Match the heat number to the material marking, check the values against the standard, confirm the issuer and signatures, and if in doubt ask the mill to confirm the certificate number.

What is a heat number on steel?

The identification number of a single melt (cast) of steel. It links the material to its chemical analysis and test results on the mill certificate.

#mill certificate#en 10204#material traceability#steel